The Most Conservative Beach Towns in Florida

Conservatism is a cultural, social, and political system that seeks to promote and preserve traditional institutions, practices, and values. In conservative beach towns, there is fast growth in the local economy, job market, and healthcare. 

To live in a range of social institutions such as the nuclear family, organized religion, the military, property rights, and monarchy, conservative towns are the places to be. Conservatives tend to favor institutions and practices that guarantee stability and evolution. This article will give you a range of beach towns to consider. 

Understanding Conservatism in Florida

Table Of Contents

The Meaning of Conservatism in Florida

Conservatism is based on a limited government, individualism, traditionalism, republicanism, and limited federal government power over U.S. states. Conservative organizations, along with American conservative figures, are influential, and American conservatism is one of the majority political ideologies within the Republican Party.

The Political and social beliefs of Conservatives in Florida

The political and social beliefs of conservatives in Florida evolve on limited government, individualism, traditionalism, republicanism, and limited federal government power over U.S. states. Socially, conservatives focus on traditional values and social institutions, such as traditional family structures, gender roles, sexual relations, national patriotism, and religious traditions.

How conservatism affects life in Florida

Conservatism allows slow change in policies, culture, and beliefs. It is suspicious and resistant to political, social, and economic change, and supports traditional ways of doing things.

Characteristics of Conservative Beach Towns in Florida

  • Low crime rates
  • Family-friendly atmosphere
  • Religious presence
  • Low taxes
  • Pro-business climate

Top 5 Conservative Beach Towns in Florida

1. Marco Island

The political climate in Marco Island is moderately conservative. 37.3% voted Democrat in the last presidential election, 61.9% voted for the Republican Party, and the remaining 0.8% voted Independent. Marco Island, FL is a small city on the Gulf of Mexico in Southwest Florida. The city has beaches, restaurants, shops, and parks. It features an active local political landscape with plenty of debate and dialogue about the future. 

Residents are more involved in politics and shape the city’s future through local initiatives like town hall forums or city council meetings. Politicians from both sides discuss issues that affect the community, such as taxes, zoning regulations, public safety, transportation, economic development initiatives, and environmental issues. City leaders focus on preserving Marco Island’s natural beauty and keeping it an attractive destination for tourists while balancing the needs of residents.

2. Sanibel Island

The political climate in Sanibel, FL is conservative. 39.9% voted Democrat in the last presidential election, 59.1% voted for the Republican Party, and the remaining 1.0% voted Independent. Sanibel is a beautiful beach town in Lee County, Florida. 

The city council consists of eight members, all of whom are affiliated with the Republican party, and the county commission for Lee County has five members, all from the Republican party. They are responsible for making decisions on development and transportation. The politics in Sanibel focus on growth and sustainability while balancing the community’s interests with environmental protection and conservation efforts.

3. Santa Rosa Beach

Santa Rosa Beach, FL is a small town along the Gulf Coast. The beach serves as a beacon of relaxation and leisure for its residents. Local issues about the environment, infrastructure, and economic development are discussed regularly in city council meetings. Elected officials from local parties are representatives of their constituents. All voices are heard in decisions that affect the community. 

Many organizations provide resources and knowledge about current political events in Santa Rosa Beach and the surrounding areas. Locals take advocacy through campaigns or attending town hall meetings with their elected officials to ensure their needs are heard. With so much activity, politics play a role in Santa Rosa Beach’s culture and daily life. The political climate in Santa Rosa Beach is strongly conservative. 23.6% voted Democrat in the last presidential election, 75.2% voted for the Republican Party, and the remaining 1.2% voted Independent.

4. Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island features a collection of tropical-style homes and friendly neighbors with golf carts. From the bay to the gulf, there is Pine Avenue. It has funky boutiques, and you can dine at local cafes. It gives you that island lifestyle. Grab a Margarita Donut or some confection from The Donut Experiment for breakfast. 

The political climate in Anna Maria is conservative. 41.5% voted Democrat in the last presidential election, 57.5% voted for the Republican Party, and the remaining 1.1% voted Independent. Anna Maria is a small coastal town in the Tampa Bay area, and politics focuses on issues that affect the local community. 

The mayor and city council have been addressing issues such as protecting the beaches, promoting economic development, and maintaining low taxes. There have been some initiatives in creating bike lanes to connect Holmes Beach with Anna Maria, improving water quality, and making the city more environmentally friendly. The town has worked hard to preserve its historical charm, preserving its old-fashioned fishing pier and centennial park. All citizens have a voice in their government, and political candidates in Anna Maria, represent the interests of all residents.

5. Key Biscayne

Key Biscayne features two picturesque beach parks and the historic Cape Florida Lighthouse. It is an island village with a sophisticated feel, close enough to Miami. It is a great place to lay on the beach with your mind off city life. You can also dine at the Rusty Pelican and still get a view of the Miami skyline.

Key Biscayne is an island town in Miami-Dade County, Florida. Its population is around 12,500 people, it is an affluent and safe community popular for its beachside resorts and excellent quality of life. Key Biscayne is represented by a two-tier system: the Village Council is a form of local government, and the Miami-Dade County Commission represents the countywide level. 

The Village Council consists of seven members, elected every two years and charged with managing the village’s budget and infrastructure projects such as road repairs. They have authority over zoning laws, refuse collection, police protection, environmental regulations, and parks and recreation. The Miami-Dade County Commission has thirteen members and serves as the legislative body for all unincorporated areas within the county. They establish ordinances regarding land use and public services. Candidates should be a resident or property owners in Key Biscayne.

Other Conservative Beach Towns in Florida


The political climate in Naples, FL is conservative. 37.3% voted Democrat in the last presidential election, 61.9% voted for the Republican Party, and the remaining 0.8% voted Independent. 

Naples is a city in southern Florida known for its beautiful beaches, vibrant culture, and lush landscapes. Naples’ politics are conservative and support local businesses through development incentives and tax exemptions. In support of local businesses, Naples also emphasizes public safety and infrastructure improvement projects. All initiatives benefit citizens and everyone in Naples feels safe and secure within their community.


The political climate in Captiva is conservative. 39.9% voted Democrat in the last presidential election, 59.1% voted for the Republican Party, and the remaining 1.0% voted Independent. 

Captiva is a small town on a barrier island off the Gulf Coast of Florida. Captiva is known for its tranquil beaches and wildlife preserves, attracting tourists and locals. The population of Captiva is small compared to other cities in Florida, but the local politics are still vibrant. Residents of Captiva elect members of their community to serve on the Town Council. 

They meet regularly to discuss issues facing the town such as development, education, infrastructure improvements, and more. Residents also vote in local elections and take part in discussions about current issues. The residents of Captiva make sure their voice is heard in local government decisions and maintain an active involvement to ensure that their interests are represented.

Pros and Cons of Living in Conservative Beach Towns in Florida


  • Sense of community
  • Lower taxes
  • Family-friendly environment
  • Low crime rates


  • Limited cultural diversity
  • Conservative beliefs may not align with some individuals


In conclusion, the most conservative beach towns in Florida take time to reflect on issues that affect the community such as taxes, zoning regulations, public safety, transportation, economic development initiatives, and environmental issues. Take your time to consider the cost of living, safety, and entertainment in Florida so you can visit or move to conservative beach towns in Florida.


What is the cost of living in conservative beach towns in Florida?

The cost of living in conservative beach towns in Florida varies significantly due to several factors:

  • Housing: Housing costs, a key contributor, vary from affordable apartments to luxury homes. Median home prices range based on proximity to the beach.
  • Utilities: Costs for electricity, water, heating, and cooling fluctuate with seasons and home efficiency.
  • Transportation: Expenses depend on your daily commute, car ownership, and town accessibility.
  • Groceries: Prices are influenced by local demand and produce availability.
  • Dining and Entertainment: Costs for eating out and entertainment vary according to preferences.
  • Healthcare: Access and insurance expenses differ; some towns offer well-equipped facilities, while others require travel for specialized care.
  • Taxes: Florida’s lack of state income tax is an advantage, but property and sales taxes vary by location.
  • Education: Quality and cost of education, including public and private schools, can be a significant factor for families.

Research specific beach towns in Florida and consider your circumstances when assessing the cost of living. Consult local listings, speak with residents, and use cost-of-living calculators for a clearer picture of expenses in your chosen town.

Are there any liberal beach towns in Florida?

Yes, several Florida beach towns are known for their diverse and liberal environments:

  • Miami: Recognized for cultural diversity, a vibrant arts scene, and progressive politics, with a thriving LGBTQ+ community.
  • Key West: Known for its laid-back, open-minded vibe and historical attraction for artists, writers, and the LGBTQ+ community.
  • Fort Lauderdale: Often seen as more progressive, with a diverse population and an inclusive attitude.
  • St. Petersburg: Boasts a thriving arts scene and embraces LGBTQ+ acceptance and advocacy.
  • Orlando: Home to a diverse population, known for cultural events, theme parks, and a vibrant LGBTQ+ community.
  • Tallahassee: As Florida’s capital, it’s a hub for political activism and progressive organizations, along with a strong academic community.
  • Daytona Beach: Known for cultural events, festivals, and a relatively diverse population.
  • Jacksonville: While a large city with diverse views, it has pockets and communities with more liberal and progressive leanings.
  • Cape Coral: Generally conservative, but Florida’s political landscape varies within cities and towns.
  • Port St. Lucie: Like many Florida cities, it has a mix of political views and has witnessed increased diversity and cultural developments.

Political views can vary within any place, and these descriptions are general perceptions. Florida’s political landscape can evolve, so considering specific context and demographics is essential when discussing political ideologies.

What are some popular attractions in conservative beach towns in Florida?

Popular attractions in conservative beach towns in Florida can vary but often include:

  • Beaches: Pristine sandy shores for relaxation and water sports like surfing, kayaking, and paddleboarding.
  • Local Seafood Restaurants: Known for excellent seafood, offering fresh catches in waterfront settings.
  • Fishing and Water Activities: Opportunities for fishing charters, boat tours, snorkeling, and scuba diving.
  • Seaside Parks and Nature Reserves: Parks, trails, and wildlife preserves for outdoor activities and birdwatching.
  • Historic Districts: Well-preserved areas with shops, galleries, and museums, offering insights into local history and culture.
  • Festivals and Events: Celebrations of local culture, music, art, and sometimes seafood.
  • Lighthouses: Historic lighthouses open for panoramic views of the area.
  • Golf Courses: Well-maintained courses with ocean views for golf enthusiasts.
  • Boating and Marinas: Options to rent boats or join sailing tours to explore the coastline.
  • Bed and Breakfast Inns: Charming accommodations for a unique and cozy stay experience.

While Apalachicola exemplifies this charm with its seafood and inns, each conservative beach town in Florida offers its unique attractions, providing a well-rounded experience of local culture and natural beauty.

Are there any job opportunities in conservative beach towns in Florida?

Yes, job opportunities exist in conservative beach towns in Florida, spanning diverse sectors:

  • Agriculture: This sector thrives in various parts of Florida, including beach towns, encompassing farming, fishing, and related roles.
  • Tourism and Hospitality: Florida’s beaches draw year-round tourists, generating job demand in hotels, restaurants, bars, and recreational services.
  • Retail: Retail businesses flourish, serving both locals and tourists. Opportunities encompass sales, customer service, and management.
  • Construction: Coastal property development and maintenance create jobs in carpentry, plumbing, and electrical work.
  • Healthcare: Some beach towns house healthcare facilities like hospitals, clinics, and retirement communities, offering positions in nursing, medical administration, and therapy.
  • Education: Local schools and educational institutions provide roles for teachers, administrators, and support staff.
  • Small Businesses: Entrepreneurship thrives in these communities, yielding jobs in local shops, boutiques, and services.
  • Remote Work: Remote work options have increased, enabling residents to work across industries without commuting.

Job availability varies by town, influenced by economic conditions, seasonal changes, and community size. Job seekers can explore local job boards, networking, and government agencies for specific town job markets.

Is there a lot of political tension in conservative beach towns in Florida?

In conservative beach towns in Florida, political tension varies based on factors like the town’s specifics, resident demographics, and current political climate. Florida’s political diversity contributes to different tension levels.

Political tension isn’t solely tied to local ideology but influenced by events, elections, and issues. Some towns have peaceful coexistence despite differing views, prioritizing beach life over politics. Others experience tension, especially during political polarization, seen in debates, yard signs, and occasional protests.

To gauge a town’s political climate, consult local news, forums, and resident discussions. Political tension can change over time.

Leave a comment